In what Israeli officials called a humanitarian gesture, planes recently began dropping aid packages over Gaza, for the first time in months. But on the ground, the reality was far different: much of that aid never made it to the civilians who need it most. Instead, it landed in areas completely inaccessible to the population, deep inside zones controlled by the Israeli military.
The airdrops were announced in coordination with Israel’s so-called "tactical pauses" in fighting, daily from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. in designated corridors including al-Mawasi, Gaza City, and Deir al-Balah. The Israeli Defense Forces claimed this effort would ease the humanitarian crisis and allow for safe passage of aid.
But civilians in northern Gaza have reported that none of the airdropped supplies reached them. In one instance, residents in Beit Lahia watched as two planes flew overhead, only to see the pallets fall over three kilometers away, deep into a military-controlled zone. No civilian could access the packages without risking their life, and few even attempted it.
A geolocated video confirms that many recent airdrops landed in areas between Jurat al-Lut and Qaizan al-Najjar. These zones are classified as "red zones" under Israeli military control. Entry is not only unsafe but impossible for the average civilian. Rather than coordinating ground distribution, Israel opted for aerial gestures that have no real impact on famine conditions.
There are over 900 trucks of aid currently waiting at Gaza’s borders. These are not being allowed in. At sea, the Freedom Flotilla was intercepted. On land, Israeli officials continue to impose arbitrary restrictions on how much aid can enter, regardless of how many people are starving.
The airdrops are being used as a substitute for actual humanitarian access. They make for good headlines and international optics but fail to provide food, water, or medicine to the civilians trapped inside Gaza. Aid groups have condemned them as inefficient, expensive, and often harmful. UN agencies have stated unequivocally that aerial aid cannot replace the volume and consistency needed to stave off starvation.
Airdrops that land in sealed-off military zones are not humanitarian relief. They are a distraction. For starving civilians in Gaza, they are just one more reminder that help remains out of reach.